In Today’s Crowded Legal Marketing Space, everyone claims to have the perfect solution to grow your firm. Every week, a new company pops up promising leads, visibility, and success. But how do you separate the real deal from the noise?

The truth is, bad marketing companies will cost you more than just money—they’ll cost you time, momentum, and trust. Here are key red flags to watch out for, as well as indicators of a marketing partner that’s actually worth your investment.

Red Flags: How to Spot a Bad Marketing Company

1. Overpromising & Underdelivering
   • Beware of companies that guarantee results they can’t back up. Phrases like “Trust me,” “If I’m being honest,” or “It was the firm’s fault” are red flags. A good partner takes accountability, not makes excuses.
2. No Proven Track Record
   • Don’t take advice from unsuccessful people or companies. If they haven’t helped others succeed, they won’t help you either. Ask for data, case studies, and real client success stories—not just flashy sales pitches.
3. Negative Reputation & Disgruntled Employees
   • A company’s reputation speaks volumes. Look beyond client testimonials—talk to their team members. If employees don’t believe in the brand they represent, they won’t be able to deliver for you. Dysfunction inside a company will show up in the service you receive.
4. Lack of Measurable Results
   • If a marketing company can’t track, measure, or forecast success, walk away. You need real data—dashboards, trends, and performance metrics—not vague promises. At Law Tigers, we measure what matters. If they can’t show results, they’re not worth your time.
5. Too Good to Be True Pricing
   • Cheaper isn’t always better. If a company is practically giving away their services, it’s usually a sign of desperation. Quality marketing isn’t about being the cheapest—it’s about delivering real ROI.
6. They Aren’t Growing Themselves
   • If a marketing company has been around for years but still has only a handful of clients, there’s a reason. Companies that can’t grow their own business won’t grow yours.

What to Look for in a Trusted Marketing Partner

1. A Reputation That Speaks for Itself
   • The best marketing firms don’t have to sell themselves—others do it for them. When their name comes up in a room, people light up, not look away.
2. Proven, Measurable Success
   • They should be able to show real numbers—not just talk a big game. A reliable marketing partner tracks, measures, and forecasts results so you know exactly what you’re getting.
3. They’re Connected with Other Successful Firms
   • Winners associate with winners. If other top firms recommend them, that’s a strong sign they deliver. Don’t be afraid to ask for references from law firms you trust.
4. Longevity & Consistency
   • New legal marketing firms pop up every month, but only the ones delivering real value stick around. Look for companies with a strong client base, consistent success, and a track record of long-term partnerships.

Final Thought: Don’t Fall for the Fake Stuff!

The legal marketing world is full of flashy salespeople, quick-fix solutions, and empty promises. Don’t get caught up in the hype—choose partners who bring real, measurable value to your firm. The right marketing company won’t just sell you a dream—they’ll help you build a sustainable and thriving practice.

David L. Thomas, MBA SVP of Growth & Business Development | ΑΦΑ

---